Early this year, the “Mohammed Cartoons” scandal inflamed Muslims, while western supporters of a free press supported the right to caricatures of, well… pretty much anybody. (For the record, Polimom was supportive of publishing the cartoons, and the target was/is immaterial.)
Many Western writers and commentators defended those cartoons as freedom of speech, freedom of expression, freedom of the press…. all part and parcel of western society.
Today, Congress is debating an amendment to the Constitution to ban desecration of the American flag, because it’s so inflammatory to American sensibilities.
Why is desecrating Old Glory worthy of a constitutional amendment, but it’s okay to lampoon Mohammed?
Just askin’…
Desecrating Old Glory
Leave a Reply
Read Next
You know, folks, I’m glad we worry so much about possible governmental intrusions into our rights and privacy. Big Brother is always lurking. Take the UK, for example… (My post at Polimom Too here). They’ve given us a lovely example …
According to the NY Times, an investigation into whether speculators are behind the run-up in energy prices has not yet found a smoking gun: As Congress debates how to curtail the role of speculators and rein in rising oil prices, …
… but it looks like you’re stuck with school for the rest of the scheduled year. CNN: Federal officials now recommend that schools stop closing when a case of swine flu is confirmed at a school, Health and Human Services …
Given the sheer volume of shrieking in the blogosphere when the story came out at TNR on Tuesday, I didn’t think this would take very long. Paul told CNN’s “The Situation Room” Thursday that he didn’t write any of the …
Uh, because the flag is the symbol of our country, while Mohammed (or Jesus, or Buddha, or W, or Clinton, or …) is a man?
It would be interesting to note how many countries criminalize the act of flag burning/desecration.
What I hope they do, during this debate, is to come up with exactly what acts they feel should be proscribed. For example, making the flag into underwear, or swin trunks, or a nose wiping cloth…
~EdT.
flag is the symbol of our country
Freedom of speech, freedom of expression, freedoms of the press are basic to the foundation of this country. If you can’t express how you feel about the country, then we wasted our time fighting the British .
Not only is the flag a symbol of our country, it symbolizes all the people/soldiers that have died protecting this country and the rights afforded to those that live here.
Funny that the scandal has a religious basis since the British came to America to enjoy religious freedom. People that live here have the freedom to chose any religion (or not) and can express their views without fear of persecution. This expands to politics and many other sensitive subjects. However, it just doesn’t make sense (to me) to burn the very symbol that allows all this, no matter what your beliefs.
It just seems like one of those things – they do it because they CAN.
Myself — I would probably not have seen an attempt to ban flag desecration through such skeptical, jaded eyes if we weren’t caught up in a fervor of nationalism and paranoia.
If we were confident rather than under threat — if this was a time of peace rather than war — and if our congresspeople were responding to a sense of pride rather than provoking anger and divisiveness for political gain.
But we’re not in such a time, and in the current climate, I’m glad it failed.